An Idea (Monster Girl Quest like)

[warlord42]

I was making The Dungeon RPGVX game, but I have turned it down for my own reasons and now I had an idea to make a slightly different mechanics. (sex fighting -> only enemies, you try to slay em down similiar to Monster Girl Quest.)

Here is what i got.

You are Sir Taylor, a great paladin which is on a quest to retrieve an ancient holy artifact. Not holy grail lol. On your journey there are girls (succubuses and other types like warriors, elfs, maids and so on.) which you need to defeat on your way aswell as solve puzzles.

Think of it as Monster Girl Quest, just that there is no game over, no overused plant monstergirls.

Let's take an Elf for example, which I made specificaly to try my mechanics
She has Blowjob and Tit Fuck abilities for an example. Meh it's hard to explain as I'm not really english so I have made this prototype:
http://filesmelt.com/dl/prototype.rar
It's a small island and the enemy (elf) shall approach you soon. Don't attack her as she has 10 hp, just guard and see how the battle will commence. That's how other battles will be. (The elf is different in every picture as it's hard to find pictures with same girls. But I think that shouldn't bother people. It doesn't bother me tbh lol.)

That's basically it. Should I continue to make the game? Feedback on idea?

[Red.Sheer]

Well, I can only provide my point of view and I think the way you are planing your game it has to be differ greatly from all the other rpg-maker games out there. I am actually not too fond of rpg-maker h-games, since the medium isn't just that great for the purpose, since you basically only playing mystic quest with random images in them. You need to provide something beside the H-content to keep them appealing and this gameplay should lead to the "reward" of having h-content. See Legend of Queen Opala games for example.

Since in your concept the battles itself is what offers the h-content you should only have very few "battles" occur at all since otherwise it gets repetetous and tedious. If I imagine I have to complete an area in which I'd have to face numerous "sex-fights" I'd be pretty much bored rather quickly, wishing to skip certain types of enemies because I already know what they are up to. Plus, If I'm not too fond of a specific fetish but fighting enemies forces me to go through a certain situation over and over I have no reason to play the game.

But it is also something which depends on what you seek in an H-RPG-Game (those are very different to the arcade ones). There are players who just play them for the lulz, wanting to see crazy hentai action and find all h-events in an game. Then there are players, like me, seeking actually a kind of erotic adventure in a game, a tension building up through the course of gameplay ecause you know that if you play your cards right you finally get a sexual reward you wanted all the time.

But thats just my point of view

[Lucky777]

It doesn't do much for me.

Part of the reason I don't play monmosu quest is that I'm annoyed to think I'd be put in the shoes of some goddamned idiot who'd see fit to resist the sexual attentions of
monstergirls in the first place, (and I can't even have 'em force-fuck some sense into his fucking head.) Unrelated to that, part of why this prototype doesn't do much for me
is that the random pictures and random short descriptions aren't particularly exciting in themselves. The action doesn't seem sustained enough, y'know?

On top of that, sexual attacks draining HP doesn't make much sense to me in the first place, so sex combat systems are kinda odd, unless they're implemented like in that
one game Smackman mentioned, the name of which I have forgotten.
I may hunt back up the post and show it to you, later when I have time. If I can be arsed, that is.

...Hell, dunno if that game is even still available, what with the bullshit that happened to Megaupload.

Well, anyway, see what some other people have to say.

[warlord42]

Thanks for the constructive criticism, I was just checking how you people like the idea, but I guess it's not that good. I'll found out something else out then. Thanks and I hope you all have a pleasant day! =)

[Lucky777]

Hey, that's only two comments out of a forum of like ... over 200 peeps. Hang on a while, hang on a while.