Hello! It's been awhile since I played through this game but it's pretty good and having been a fan of Humbird0's games I was pleasantly intrigued by it. I'm happy to hear that you guys haven't given up on it. Also I would like to mention something regarding these messages:
Dead2112man Wrote:obviouslyanalias Wrote:Hey, you do realize that once you open source something, it is open source for good, right? That's the whole point of open source, you can't just change your mind and close source it. Sure you can change the licence on future assets, but those already in the public domain stay licensed under whatever they were originally released with. You can only make things less closed source retrospectively. You can ask for attribution, but that is in itself a specific license that should be included with the source material.
Not trying to start shit, but your main post is spreading misinformation. Whatever assets were available in the license before your post edit are fair use. If you want control of your assets you need to ship the licensing info with the product. Keep it in mind for the future, so you don't get into flame wars with other developers.
.....
You know, a good way to not try to start things, would be not bring it up
.....
And no, Open source project sure, the stuff that we initily used are open source for they were made for Humbird0's game. But the stuff we have made, specifically for this they have never been open sourced. And no, we are not spreading misinformation, that has been a thing from when we started to create are own assets. DapperGent has just had to make it more clear cut after the a previous issue that did not resolve well for either party.
Really flame wars? is that still a term people use for internet fights.
and this from the main post:
"As of June 20th, 2017, the resources created by Dark Impulses, including tile sets, sprites and artwork, are no longer open source for public use. If you or someone you know is currently using our resources please contact us immediately."
First of all, I really don't think its inappropriate for someone to point out what seems to be an inconsistency. I think most people understand that its not logical to say that something is now no longer open source, and that is what that quote from the main post implies. It could (and should imo) also mean that everything new made for the game going forward is no longer open source. (Also, you really don't need to be coming off as rude to someone on a forum, it just looks bad on your team.)
Anyhow, I don't mean this to be inflammatory, but maybe its a good learning experience, and more optimistically, a good thing this issue has been addressed as early on as it has.
With that in mind I think its necessary to point out that the game client doesn't have a disclaimer, the game files don't have a readme, and the credits.txt make no mention of intellectual property apart from this fun bit:
'Disclaimer
Copyrighted works are
copyright to the
copyright holders who
copyrighted them
Ownership
Pokemon's the intellectual property of GameFreaks
Pokemon is an emotional property of childhood
Pokemon is a fundamental property of fandom
Pokemon are the private property of Ash
Pokemon was produced by Nintendo
Pokemon have reproduced with each other
Pokemon have been reimagined by their fans.'
However there is a game editor.
Personally I think you guys should be the ones benefiting from your work, I mean like its obvious you put real effort and time into it, but it would make sense to me that with the new engine and refresh of the game would be your closed source starting off point, and just keep going from there, having it be one of those ridiculously well funded patreon games. You don't really see someone hijacking your game and then seriously competing with it do you? Anyway sorry if this post is irrelevant, dumb, outdated or whatever but I really mean to encourage you guys. This style of game ought to be immortal ; )
(and on a side note, I would have sent a pm to dapper but my account is too new to allow that :/ )