May be i am a Captain Obvious again
- as i am always
- but what i can say to you:
What is game:
Algoritms (movie algoritms / calculations / simple games in game algoritms / server based algoritms / drawing algoritms).
Art (Animation/BackGrounds/Charecter/design/menu design).
And game play (Story / Ingame dialogs and idea).
Music (Music and sound effects).
No one can do all of this alone. (Exept may be Gorepete
- he make a really big work
it is really amazing
)
Just for example - you need to take sound and music some where. All sounds from some where. Okay may be you have some source where you can take it good.
Art and animation. There are a lot of 3d arts - but all of them looks the same and are using everywhere. For example 3d arts of Krystal - it is as i understand and very interesting. But to make some thing like this is really hard and takes time. So you need to find a different sources of where you can take nt common animations / arts and etc - it will take a lot of time. More will take only to make it yourself
Story - for example you create a story but you can not find a charecter that you use in it - what will you do then ? Change dialogs / and game idea or draw this charecter ? So better you already have to collect all content you need before you will do story or you have to be ready to make any of this yourself - for 3d it is really hard work.
Algoritms - for 3d you will ned or use not relly 3d just like movie from program that create it. Or use some 3d algoritms - but where and what to use ? May be even use another source for it. But if so where to take progrsammists for that ? Or may be to take already ready codes from another games and just change animations there ? To make 3d algoritms by yourself from zero is not a hard problem. It is OMFG !!! It is much more bigger and harder ! I work a little with 3d animations and graphics in the institute - and i can say it is not even a little ass ache - it is like hole in head that is more than head itself - it is realy painful thing that takes a lot of time. Thats why you always here - that company use algoritms from bla bla bla game. Yes becouse they can not make there own ! Ant that people to they take another games and a little change it. And its process is going for a long time i think. So to make it by a small group is bad idea.
--- --- ---
Now lets think why 3d is good ? All old games was 2d - and they were interesting to play. All 3 d gives us is - you have story line buuut - you can go in another direction. You can for example look on the garbage in a lot of angles - or look on amazing tree. Woooow 3 d tree - i can see it in real life every day. You get no action at all. By the way you newer use all the directions of 3 d in games. You only use the best - so what for to draw other ?
So 2d is good. Really good as i think. The only one reason when 3d is good that you can look on your charecter in difrent angles - some times it is really interesting. But if she do nothing it will not be interesting long - and it more simple to make it 2d and make just more good designed views of your charecter.
By the way 3d eats more memory space. And it is really good if you want the game be harder to download
Even some games that were 2d and were remade to be 3d do not become better - they do not. Just a lot of people do not see the original of them - so do I. I sai wow what a cool game but then when i play original i say wtf what the shit was the 3d version. Yes a lot of old 2 d games were interesting but they have bad graphics and animation becouse of low powered machines of that time - but it is not a reason to try to make them 3d.
The life is 3d - and it is full of boring moments shit !
I mean some times =))) Yes it is 3d but it do not make it more interesting at all - only interesting actions are. So do in games too i think.
It is only my opinion may be i am even not right - but i think so
By the way 3d island on flash will be just a movie am i write - if so and if you want it to look like 3d may be it is possible to use some kind of 2d stuff - for example Movie like avi from some where to make world look like 3d. And for example just add some elements you need to it on flash ? If think so - all 3 d is 2d - with just some new angles added ? What of them are the best ? Put them in game and it will be perfect - and will not be boring while player will find them by himself