"Mhm, perhaps you will last longer on this island of ours than some of the last few who found their way here." It hums, and says, "The offer to join in the fun remains, though if you accept, it will just be simple fun in this dream. My powers will only let me play further with your mind if you are openly willing."
It then shrugs. "Or of course, you can simply watch these two have fun and I will leave you to the remainder of this dream. It'll end when they finish in your friends~"
While a part of you is inclined not to believe this... Dream entity, you don't get any feeling of deception. You suppose after a fashion indulging would be like having fun in a lucid dream? Though you could also simply say no again. The dream might even actually end if you really focus on waking up! If this thing, or person, is messing with you, it could be messing with Candy and James! For all you knew this was a shared dream of some sort and he was doing something to them!
Spoiler (click to show/hide):