Mole Studio Wrote:We wanted to make a game about Demacia and then we had these ideas about Sona... So since we already worked on Sona, we wanted to link the two projects. And that's because of that obsession I had to break this idea as soon as possible, so he can take some distance and think more about it.
I'm aware of that tonal shift and to be honest that was totally intended, I wanted to keep the tone of ANWS and then include elements that make the story more complex. The world of LOL is not that simple and during the game fun moments and more serious will alternate. This wedding is still hiding some secrets and I hope it will help to make the story denser. The problem with your idea is that's it's a bit cliché to me and to be honest, that was our first idea. That said, with so much negative feedback about the Sona part, I will try to lighten what I planned. xD
With the events of Update1 he realized that Sona has to be seen as a person, she is not a VG Character anymore and he can't just love here because he is a fanboy... That said, Sona is your only hope of going back in your world so you need to meet her again and then you will decide what to do. We are not in ANWS anymore and at the end the player only will decide the character he wants to end with. At least, we want to allow that. There is still something but the MC's obsession for Sona is part of the past. With the numerous potential waifus in the game we need this, our we will be unable to advance haha xD Will try to make my intentions clearer in update 2, and I hope people will understand ^^
Oh absolutely. It's definitely a cliche idea, 100%. Having a Hero saving a woman from a forced marriage (at the last minute!) is definitely an expected trope. But then, having the girl he's obsessed with sucked out of his computer to be with him (for one night only) is just as cliche, and so is a hero being suddenly transported into a fantasy world (you can go right back to Mark Twain with that one, possibly even further). Hell, so is the Hero being able to have sex with someone like Ahri without issues. It's all pretty cliche and it's all pandering.
And that's not a bad thing. Many things are cliches because they work or because they can be good building blocks for stories. You don't have to follow them of course, and it's often good to make a concerted effort not to...
But, NTR is a pretty damn specific fetish and the idea of Your Character being NTR'd (rather than doing it) even more so. Having the game literally sit you down and listen to the woman you're interested in having sex with another guy is a big jump from pandering to a gut punch (and personally, I'd argue you took a bit of a cop out by having the MC not all that affected by it. He's got much more of an "Oh that sucks" attitude than the "WTF!? NO!" I'd expect from being forced to listen to the woman he loves with someone else, and then having her explain that she married him from her free will and is happily married).
So rather than a quest to save the woman he loves from a terrible fate, it's a quest to break up the (mostly) happy marriage of the woman he's obsessed with, after she turned down wanting to be with him and is quite happy sleeping with her husband the whole time. Unless you're going for a villainous hero route, you can see why that's not quite as compelling?
I assume there'll be a big twist where it turns out her husband is evil and he's got evil plans and we need to stop him, so it's all for the greater good, but ehhh, I'll see. Plus it then makes me consider, what about the rest of the story? We're seeing Katarina with Garen, which is great, a pairing that's pretty popular, but if we're gonna have the MC being NTR'd are we then gonna have him go around doing that to others? Stealing Kat from Garen, Ashe from Trynd etc, again, it's a pretty specific fetish.
Honestly, I'd think there'd be room for the guy just to grow on his mission. He's obsessed with Sona but realises that he only knows her as a game character, not as a person, he's got his quest to save her, but she's a distant figure and in the meantime Ahri needs him, so he makes compromises, and then more, and then... Things change, he moves past an obsession and grows up.
Anyhow, I'll stop going on about this because it's probably a pretty pointless argument (the plot being set and all), I just wanted to explain why I was so put off by Update 1, especially after the previous work. I do want to support this and after I came back to it I enjoyed the rest of it, I think the art is great and I'll look out for Update2 when it does drop, just perhaps, I'm not so interested in saving Sona from her happy marriage, especially when she wasn't all that concerned about it/the MC.
One final nitpick though: The aftermath of the Ahri sex scene didn't really make a whole lot of sense, that is, why was the MC so surprised by Ahri's reaction?
He knows Ahri (obviously) he's even probably pretty damn familiar with her (He had an Ahri-Sona body pillow). We know he follows the lore because he knows Sona's husband is non-canon and even if he only truly follows the Sona lore, you'd expect him to at least know the very basic things about the other characters, but he doesn't know anything about Ahri's story? About why she's feeding on humans and what happens to those she's with? It seemed very odd for him to be so surprised that she was surprised about his (unexplained) survival.
I think one of the strong points about this character is that he already (mostly/somewhat) knows all the people involved, Fiora doesn't have to introduce herself, we know her and he knows her, that kind'a thing. It gives him an advantage in this world and room to move... But instead it seems he doesn't know even the basics?
Anyhow, as I said, just a minor nitpick, not something to lose sleep about.