Game ideas, chosing one and wanting feedback

[RodneyPP]

(( first of all, sorry moderator for deleting this, it wasn't intentionally ^^U ))

Hello, I'm new here and this is my first post and sorry for the bad english I'll write.
I know this forum since a lot of time and I love it, but I neved posted before because reasons.

Well, I wanted to make an adult game project since a lot of time, but I didn't started because random reasons.
Now I decided to start one with Game Maker. But I need an "idea" to make reality.

So, 2 days ago I played Girl vs Girl (an H game based in the SNES game "Spy vs Spy") and it was awesome. Then I said to myself "Why not an old school remake?".
So I started to search in my gammer chilhood and I remembered 2 good titles: "The Lost Vikings" and "Haunting: Starring Polterguy", later searching some more I discovered "Dungeon Keeper" and it inspired me a little more.


Then, I open this thread to talk about the 3 ideas I had, about witch one select and about aporting some ideas for it.


IDEAS:

1) The Lost Vikings' based game.

(for who don't know the game... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l-1wmfle9-8 ).
A puzzle based plataform game about 3 vikings (valkyries?) where each one has unique skills. Combining their abilities you guide the 3 vikings (all alive!) to the end of each level, solving the puzzles of each scenario.

How to make it a Hentai game?
Think about making the vikings as valkyries (or maybe one can be a banshee/witch or something). Alternativelly the characters can be monster girls, something like a succubus, a neko and a fairy, or another monster.
The point is that you can solve some puzzles with sex, like masturbating to fill a pail with vaginal juices and using it as a weight. Or getting raped by a moster to distract it while the other two can pass without danger.

Here I'll need A LOT of imagination an ideas aporting to make it funny, sexy and of course playable.



2) Haunting: starring Polterguy's based game.

(here you can see a gameplay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rggV0jFxgK4&list=PL3E46C5AA0BC2E173 ).
A normal family is moving to their new house, you are a ghost. The objetive of the game is to scare the family and making them to leave the house. You can manipulate objects possessing them, ex: taking possesion of a chair, then the chair becomes a demon chair with a gyant mouth spitting blood, and when somebody looks at it, they get scared.

How to make it a Hentai game?
Simple, first, think about a only female family, like lesbians with a teen adopted daugher, or something like a students group coexisting to share the rent, maybe can include a gay dude (?).
Then, you posses objects not to only scare them, maybe you can rape them. Think about taking possesion of a teddy bear, then it grows a cock and you rape a girl throw the possesed bear.
Maybe you can get 2 finals: one scaring the family making them to run away. Or making them orgasm so much than they "feel in love" with the house's phantom.

Here also I'll a lot of ideas and imagination, the concept is easier, just designing the animations, but it will cost a lot more sprite design.




3) Dungeon Keeper's based game.

(here a gameplay: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AO0BapJsSK0 ).
This one is not an old school game, but I am here to talk about concepts, not about just old school remakes :v.
Basically is a Real Time Strategy where we are the bad guys. You manage a dungeon, grow up creatures and defend from Heroes' attacks. Objective is conquest the human world.

How to make it a Hentai game?
MONSTER GURLZ FTW! Tons of monstergirls, succubus, vampires, lamias, ponies, spiders, nekos, centaurs, witchs, etc. Also fem enemies like nuns, fairies, elfs, angels, tons of etc. The creation of new units is made by breeding. You defend your dungeon with monsters, monsters can be A) monster girls \o/, B) rapists monsters like orcs or minotaurs, so you can rape female heroes. Maybe you can also capture them and use them for breeding or feeding succubus or something like that.

This one may be a little more complex than the others at programming. Ideas are also wellcome.

----


So, there are my 3 ideas for hentai game projects. I post it because I want opinions about which one make first, and because I want ideas, tons of ideas.

See you later guys! I want feedback :v

[Tovaritx]

I like the 2nd idea

the Haunting

you can get inspiration for that also in the movie of 1982, the Entity.

Sheer up!

[Grosham]

Hmmm...
As far as sex content goes, the Haunting looks like it has the most potential. The game would be centered on raping the girls, after all. Here are some quick ideas off the top of my head:
Toilet gives an enema
Curtains tie a girl up in the window, facing out; add something else to take her from behind
Garden hose goes tentacle
Shower doesn't have to be water
Dining room chairs are vibrators
And (should he be included) whenever the gay guy shows up you have to knock him out somehow. I picture him as muscular and narcissistic, so using a mirror to distract him and clubbing him with the baseball bat would be one option.
My vote goes for commune over lesbian family. Smart girl with glasses, small redhead, delinquent, closet lesbian; it has so many more options.
It would be a lot of work doing the sprites, but the payout would be fantastic.

Conversely, I'd choose Dungeon Keeper for actual gameplay. The center of the game would be world domination, with female domination being a side. It would probably be more difficult to do all the programming and balancing, but once finished it would be a game with great replayability.

I can't choose between the two, so I'll give each a half vote. Which one I would want to play would depend entirely on my mood at the time. Still, whichever game is picked, I wish you great success. These ideas all look terrific.

[ArdenWolfwatcher]

I agree on Haunting having the most potential for a H-game, but the Dungeon Keeper seems like the one with the strongest gameplay and replay value (it also helps that I'm a big fan of RTS games in the first place), I'm just unsure of how the H-content would work for an RTS game. Would the gameplay stop or keep going as we watched our orcs fight/fuck the light side's elves, or would they fight and the one that ran out of HP first get fucked by the winner who becomes invulnerable to damage for the duration of the animation before being able to be controlled again?

[codered999]

You can set up an actual voting thing like everyone else at the top of the thread. Before you do that I vote for the raping house partly because it doesn't have to be a family of only one gender, by which I mean as you the spirit gains more power and can do more things with the objects in the house you can force people to violate one another like using curtains to hold and hide someone, then use a chair to hold someone else in place, and have the chair move over to the curtains and everything would unfold into those two being forced into whatever you have in mind.

[Elerneron]

You add the ability to possess the living and mixed genders and the Haunting game could be one of my favorite game concepts in a long time . . . especially if those moving in are family. I have a huge interest in incest in games.

[jerkface]

Let me start by saying this: If you are still on the idea stage and don't have enough confidence in yourself to pick a path to go down, I'm not confident that the final product is going to turn out well.

On a more optimistic note: if you aren't a professional developer with years of experience, anything more than a rough idea is going to be pretty much superfluous at this point. Your game will only start to really solidify once you've got something working and you're able to play around with it. So I'll give you a nice feasibility analysis:

The Lost Vikings:
This idea is probably the one with the best chance of getting made and being good. It's fairly simple to get something working and then you can play around with it and enjoy adding new mechanics and not sweat too hard if you have to cut some things. This sort of game is also fairly light on art assets as well. The biggest challenge would be smoothly integrating porn content with the gameplay.

Haunting:
I see three main issues with this game idea: it is extremely dependent on art, you'll need lots of good writing as well but you don't seem to be a native English speaker, and the programming is so simple that it will get boring. If you want to make this game I suggest using static images taken from around the internet for porn content and finding yourself a good editor.

Dungeon Keepers:
This is going to be the hardest to make, simply because you'll need to deal with at least semi-sophisticated AI. However, I like this idea best because it will offer actual gameplay with a lot of replayability and the format allows for easy integration of "recycled" assets as well as a feedback loop that makes sense (aka. you get porn when you do good rather than when you do bad). If you're confident in your programming ability I'd say go for this one. If trying to understand the A* algorithm fills you with dread and confusion, do something else.

[thechosenwaffle]

I'd love to see option 3, as it has the potential for lots of variety if the work is put into it....but that's just the thing. It would require more work imo. In the end, I feel that it comes down to whatever you want the most and feel like doing

[Terrantor!!!]

I'd love a new rendition of Lost Vikings even without the hentai, lol. That would be interesting to pull off with hentai, though. As for the the the haunted house, one, I've got some isometric tiles you're free to use, just pm me if interested.

[QuizmasterBos]

Regarding idea 2: viewtopic.php?f=28&t=2972
I think this is almost the exact same thing you are describing.

I kinda like idea 1, but it would require a lot of work to design a good level like that. Especially if you want to make it a full-fledged game.

Idea 3 sounds very familiar to me. Don't tell me this doesn't exist in some form already. I'm not too knowledgeable about monster girls, but I'm sure someone has already made something with them.

[Terrantor!!!]

Agreed. For the lost vikings, you can get zelda to use magic sheilds, and gliding. Samus can be the offensive with her gun and lash. Krystal can be the agility with jumping and a a jump-kick instead of a head butt.